Skip First Level Navigation | Skip All Navigation

Maine.gov > PFR Home > Insurance Regulation > All Hearing Decisions > All Hearing Decisions Index

Hearing Decisions

Hearings Schedule

This page contains Decisions and Orders issued by the Superintendent of Insurance in matters that were decided by a formal hearing.

On This Page: Form A/Reorganization | Rate Filings | Workers' Compensation | Other

Form A/Reorganization

Form A/Reorganization
Insurance Co. Description Docket No.
Acadia Insurance Co. Request of Compensation Mutual Insurance Company to Convert to a Stock Insurance Company and Request of Acadia Insurance Company to Acquire Control of Compensation Mutual Insurance Company INS-98-16
Acadia Insurance Co. Application by Berkley Regional Insurance Company Corporation to Acquire Control of Acadia Insurance Company INS-96-24
Aetna Inc. Form A Application of Aetna Inc. to Acquire Control of NYLCARE Health Plans of Maine, Inc., a subsidiary of New York Life Insurance Company INS-98-5
Allied Zurich P.L.C. Form A Application of Allied Zurich P.L.C., Allied Zurich Holdings Limited, Zurich Financial Services, Zurich Insurance Company and Zurich Allied AG to Acquire Control of Maine Bonding and Casualty Company, an indirect subsidiary of Zurich Insurance Company INS-98-7
American Colonial Insurance Co. Application of North East Insurance Company and American Colonial Insurance Company for Approval of an Agreement and Plan of Merger INS-03-407
Anthem Health Plans of Maine Application of Anthem Health Plans of Maine, Inc. dba Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield for approval of an agreement and plan of merger with Maine Partners Health Plan, Inc. INS-04-410
Anthem Health Plans of Maine Application of Anthem Health Plans of Maine, Inc., dba Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield, For Approval of an Agreement and Plan of Merger with Central Maine Partners Health Plan, Inc. INS-00-3025
Anthem Health Plans of Maine Decision of the Superintendent in the Anthem/Blue Cross Transaction and Other Documents INS-99-14
Banc One Private Mortgage Insurance Co. Application of Banc One Private Mortgage Insurance Company, Inc. for approval of an agreement and plan of merger with Cross Country Insurance Company. INS-05-401
Banc One Private Mortgage Insurance Co. (Final Order) Form A Statement Regarding the Acquisition of or Merger with Banc One Private Mortgage Insurance Company by J.P. Morgan Chase & Co. INS-04-400 (Final)
Banc One Private Mortgage Insurance Co. Form A Statement Regarding the Acquisition of or Merger with Banc One Private Mortgage Insurance Company by J.P. Morgan Chase & Co. INS-04-400
Berkley Regional Insurance Co. Application by Berkley Regional Insurance Company Corporation to Acquire Control of Acadia Insurance Company INS-96-24
Cadillac Mountain Insurance Co. Application of Selective Insurance Group, Inc. for Approval of Acquisition of Control of Cadillac Mountain Insurance Company Pursuant to Stock Purchase Agreement INS 03-439
Central Maine Partners Health Plan, Inc. Application of Anthem Health Plans of Maine, Inc., dba Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield, For Approval of an Agreement and Plan of Merger with Central Maine Partners Health Plan, Inc. INS-00-3025
Central Maine Partners Health Plan, Inc. Application of Central Maine Partners Health Plan INS-96-16
CIGNA Health Corp. Form A Filing of CIGNA Health Corporation, acting through CHC Acquisition Corp., to Acquire Control of Healthsource Maine, Inc., a subsidiary of Healthsource, Inc. INS-97-4
Commercial Union York Insurance Co. Form A Statement of White Mountains Insurance Group LTD., White Mountains Holdings (Barbados) SRL, WM Asset Management (Barbados) Ltd., WM Bridgetown (Barbados) Ltd., WM Enterprises (Barbados) Ltd., Tack Holding Corp., Tack Acquisition Corp. and Mr. John J. Byrne Pertaining to the Acquisition of Control of Commercial Union York Insurance Company INS-00-3031
Commercial Union York Insurance Co. Form A Statement of White Mountains Insurance Group Ltd., White Mountains Holdings (Barbados) SRL, Tack Holding Corp. and Tack Acquisition Corp. Pertaining to the Acquisition of Control of Commercial Union York Insurance Company INS-00-3031
Commercial Union York Insurance Co. Form A Filing of Commercial Union Insurance Company Pertaining to the Acquisition of Control of York Insurance Company of Maine INS-97-10
Compensation Mutual Insurance Co. Request of Compensation Mutual Insurance Company to Convert to a Stock Insurance Company and Request of Acadia Insurance Company to Acquire Control of Compensation Mutual Insurance Company INS-98-16
Cross Country insurance Co. Application of Banc One Private Mortgage Insurance Company, Inc. for approval of an agreement and plan of merger with Cross Country Insurance Company. INS-05-401
Healthsource Maine, Inc. Form A Filing of CIGNA Health Corporation, acting through CHC Acquisition Corp., to Acquire Control of Healthsource Maine, Inc., a subsidiary of Healthsource, Inc. INS-97-4
J.P. Morgan Chase & Co. (Final Order) Form A Statement Regarding the Acquisition of or Merger with Banc One Private Mortgage Insurance Company by J.P. Morgan Chase & Co. INS-04-400 (Final)
J.P. Morgan Chase & Co.; Form A Statement Regarding the Acquisition of or Merger with Banc One Private Mortgage Insurance Company by J.P. Morgan Chase & Co. INS-04-400
Maine Bonding and Casualty Co Form A Application of Allied Zurich P.L.C., Allied Zurich Holdings Limited, Zurich Financial Services, Zurich Insurance Company and Zurich Allied AG to Acquire Control of Maine Bonding and Casualty Company, an indirect subsidiary of Zurich Insurance Company INS-98-7
Maine Mutual Fire Insurance Co. Application of Maine Mutual Fire Insurance Company for Approval of Plan to Reorganize as a Stock Insurer within a Mutual Holding Company Structure INS-01-2536
Maine Partners Health Plan, Inc. Application of Anthem Health Plans of Maine, Inc. dba Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield for approval of an agreement and plan of merger with Maine Partners Health Plan, Inc. INS-04-410
Maine Partners Health Plan, Inc. Application of Maine Partners Health Plan INS-96-11
Motor Club of America Form A Filing of Motor Club of America, Acting Through NEIC Insurance Acquisition Corporation, Pertaining to the Acquisition of Control by Merger of North East Insurance Company INS-99-7
Motor Club of America Amended Decision and Order - Form A Filing of Motor Club of America, Acting Through NEIC Insurance Acquisition Corporation, Pertaining to the Acquisition of Control by Merger of North East Insurance Company INS-99-7 (Amended)
North East Insurance Co. Application of Tower Group, Inc. and Tower Insurance Company of New York for Approval of the Proposed Acquisition of Control by Merger of North East Insurance Company INS-06-410
North East Insurance Co. Application of North East Insurance Company and American Colonial Insurance Company for Approval of an Agreement and Plan of Merger INS-03-407
North East Insurance Co. Form A Filing of Motor Club of America, Acting Through NEIC Insurance Acquisition Corporation, Pertaining to the Acquisition of Control by Merger of North East Insurance Company INS-99-7
North East Insurance Co. Amended Decision and Order - Form A Filing of Motor Club of America, Acting Through NEIC Insurance Acquisition Corporation, Pertaining to the Acquisition of Control by Merger of North East Insurance Company INS-99-7 (Amended)
NYLCARE Health Plans of Maine, Inc. Form A Application of Aetna Inc. to Acquire Control of NYLCARE Health Plans of Maine, Inc., a subsidiary of New York Life Insurance Company INS-98-5
Patriot Mutual Insurance Co. Application of Patriot Mutual Insurance Company for Approval to Reorganize as a Stock Insurer within a Mutual Holding Company Structure and Application of Frankenmuth Mutual Insurance Company for Approval of the Acquisition of Control by Merger of the Reorganized Patriot Companies INS-06-400
Amendment No. 1
Patriot Mutual Insurance Co. Application of Patriot Mutual Insurance Company for Approval to Reorganize as a Stock Insurer within a Mutual Holding Company Structure and Application of Frankenmuth Mutual Insurance Company for Approval of the Acquisition of Control by Merger of the Reorganized Patriot Companies INS-06-400
Patrons-Oxford Mutual Insurance Co. Request of Patrons-Oxford Mutual Insurance Company to Convert to a Stock Insurance Company and Request of Quincy Mutual Fire Insurance Company to Acquire Control of Patrons-Oxford Mutual Insurance Company INS-97-17
Provident Companies, Inc. Form A Application of Provident Companies, Inc. and Hugh O. MacLellan, Jr. Pertaining to the Acquisition of Control of UNUM Life Insurance Company of America INS-99-1
Quincy Mutual Fire Insurance Co. Request of Patrons-Oxford Mutual Insurance Company to Convert to a Stock Insurance Company and Request of Quincy Mutual Fire Insurance Company to Acquire Control of Patrons-Oxford Mutual Insurance Company INS-97-17
Selective Insurance Group, Inc. Application of Selective Insurance Group, Inc. for Approval of Acquisition of Control of Cadillac Mountain Insurance Company Pursuant to Stock Purchase Agreement INS-03-439
Tack Holding Corp., Tack Acquisition Corp. Form A Statement of White Mountains Insurance Group LTD., White Mountains Holdings (Barbados) SRL, WM Asset Management (Barbados) Ltd., WM Bridgetown (Barbados) Ltd., WM Enterprises (Barbados) Ltd., Tack Holding Corp., Tack Acquisition Corp. and Mr. John J. Byrne Pertaining to the Acquisition of Control of Commercial Union York Insurance Company INS-00-3031
Tack Holding Corp., Tack Acquisition Corp. Form A Statement of White Mountains Insurance Group Ltd., White Mountains Holdings (Barbados) SRL, Tack Holding Corp. and Tack Acquisition Corp. Pertaining to the Acquisition of Control of Commercial Union York Insurance Company INS-00-3031
UNUM Life Insurance Company of America Form A Application of Provident Companies, Inc. and Hugh O. MacLellan, Jr. Pertaining to the Acquisition of Control of UNUM Life Insurance Company of America INS-99-1
White Mountains Insurance Group Ltd. Form A Statement of White Mountains Insurance Group LTD., White Mountains Holdings (Barbados) SRL, WM Asset Management (Barbados) Ltd., WM Bridgetown (Barbados) Ltd., WM Enterprises (Barbados) Ltd., Tack Holding Corp., Tack Acquisition Corp. and Mr. John J. Byrne Pertaining to the Acquisition of Control of Commercial Union York Insurance Company INS-00-3031
White Mountains Insurance Group Ltd. Form A Statement of White Mountains Insurance Group Ltd., White Mountains Holdings (Barbados) SRL, Tack Holding Corp. and Tack Acquisition Corp. Pertaining to the Acquisition of Control of Commercial Union York Insurance Company INS-00-3031
York Insurance Company of Maine Form A Filing of Commercial Union Insurance Company Pertaining to the Acquisition of Control of York Insurance Company of Maine INS-97-10
Zurich Insurance Co. Form A Application of Allied Zurich P.L.C., Allied Zurich Holdings Limited, Zurich Financial Services, Zurich Insurance Company and Zurich Allied AG to Acquire Control of Maine Bonding and Casualty Company, an indirect subsidiary of Zurich Insurance Company INS-98-7

Rate Filings

   
American Progressive Life & Health Insurance Company of New York 2004 Rate Filings for Individual Standardized Medicare Supplement Policies INS-04-610
Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield 2008 Individual Rate Filing for HealthChoice and HealthChoice Standard and Basic Products INS-07-1000
Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield 2007 Individual/Self-Employed Employer Rate Filing for DirigoChoice Products INS-06-1030
Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield 2007 Individual/Self-Employed Employer Rate Filing for DirigoChoice Products INS-06-1030
Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield 2007 Individual/Self-Employed Employer Rate Filing for DirigoChoice Products INS-06-1030
(Revised Filing)
Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield 2007 Individual/Self-Employed Employer Rate Filing for DirigoChoice Products INS-06-1030
Attachment A
Attachment B
Excel Spreadsheets
Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield 2007 Companion Plan Rate Filing INS-06-1010
Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield 2007 Individual Rate Filing for HealthChoice and HealthChoice Standard and Basic Products INS-06-1000
Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield 2007 Individual Rate Filing for HealthChoice Standard and Basic Products INS-06-1000
(Final)
Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield 2007 Individual Rate Filing for HealthChoice Standard and Basic Products INS-06-1000
Attachments A and B
Attachment C
Attachment D
Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield 2006 Individual Rate Filing for Healthchoice and Healthchoice Standard and Basic Products INS-05-820
Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield; (Final Order) 2006 Individual Rate Filing for Healthchoice and Healthchoice Standard and Basic Products INS-05-820 (Final)
Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield 2006 Rate Filings for Companion Plan Products INS-05-800
Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield (Final Order) 2006 Rate Filings for Companion Plan Products INS-05-800 (Final)
Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield 2005 Individual Rate Filing for Companion Plan Products INS-04-620
Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield 2005 Individual Rate Filing for HealthChoice, HealthChoice Standard and Basic Products (Revised) INS-04-610 (Final)
Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield 2005 Individual Rate Filing for HealthChoice, HealthChoice Standard and Basic Products INS-04-610
Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield 2003 Individual Rate Filing for Healthchoice, Healthchoice Standard and Basic, and Individual HMO Standard and Basic Products - Revised Rates INS-02-785 (Final)
Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield 2003 Individual Rate Filing for Healthchoice, Healthchoice Standard and Basic, and Individual HMO Standard and Basic Products INS-02-785
Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield 2002 Individual Rate Filing for Healthchoice, Healthchoice Standard and Basic, and Individual HMO Standard and Basic Products, and INS 01-2534 - Maine Partners Health Plan 2002 Individual Rate Filing INS-01-2532 and INS-01-2534
Bankers Life and Casualty Company 2004 Rate Filings for Individual and Group Standardized Medicare Supplement Policies INS-03-432
Bankers Life and Casualty Company 2002 Rate Filing for Medicare Supplement Policies INS-01-2549
Blue Cross and Blue Shield Nongroup Rate Filing for Healthchoice, Healthchoice Standard and Basic, and Individual HMO Standard and Basic Products INS-99-9
Mega Life and Health Insurance Co. Rates for Individual Health Plans - Order Regarding Refunds Required by the Superintendent's Decision Order INS-08-1000
Mega Life and Health Insurance Co. Rates for Individual Health Plans INS-08-1000
United Healthcare Company 2007 Rate Filings for Medicare Supplement Plan Products INS-06-1020
Washington National Insurance Co. 2003 Rate Filings for Individual Major Medical Expense Policies INS-03-403

Workers' Compensation

   
Acadia Insurance Co. Network Trade Corporation v. Acadia Insurance Company INS-00-10
American Interstate Insurance Co. Portland Airport Limousine Co., Inc., dba Palco Air Cargo v. American Interstate Insurance Company and National Council on Compensation Insurance, Inc. INS-04-102
Ford Insurance Agency, Inc. Terravecchia Building and Restoration, Inc. v. Maine Employers' Mutual Insurance Company and Ford Insurance Agency, Inc. INS-04-103
Hanover Insurance Co. Roland and Janice Husset dba Hussey's Paint and Decorating v. Hanover Insurance Company and National Council on Compensation Insurance INS-02-504
Legion Insurance Co. Town of Buxton v. Legion Insurance Company (In Rehabilitation) INS-03-409
Legion Insurance Co. Bernard Ginn & Sons, Inc. v. Legion Insurance Company INS-02-753
Liberty Mutual Insurance Co. Support Solutions, Inc. v. Maine Employers' Mutual Insurance Company and Liberty Mutual Insurance Company INS-04-104
Maine Employers' Mutual Insurance Co. Crosswinds Air, Inc. v. Maine Employers' Mutual Insurance Company INS-08-109
Maine Employers' Mutual Insurance Co. Bruce Fadden dba Custom Building and Remodeling v. Maine Employers' Mutual Insurance Company INS-08-105
Maine Employers' Mutual Insurance Co. Alley Builders, Inc. v. Maine Employers' Mutual Insurance Company INS-08-104
Maine Employers' Mutual Insurance Co. Anthony Keefe Enterprises, Inc. v. Maine Employers' Mutual Insurance Company INS-08-103
Maine Employers' Mutual Insurance Co. Wayne Gleason v. Maine Employers' Mutual Insurance Company INS-08-102
Maine Employers' Mutual Insurance Co. Lane Home Builders, Inc. v. Maine Employers' Mutual Insurance Company INS-08-100
Reconsideration
Maine Employers' Mutual Insurance Co. Lane Home Builders, Inc. v. Maine Employers' Mutual Insurance Company INS-08-100
Maine Employers' Mutual Insurance Co. Woodbury, Inc. v. Maine Employers' Mutual Insurance Company INS-07-100
Maine Employers' Mutual Insurance Co. James Peterson dba Red Oak Forestry v. Maine Employers' Mutual Insurance Company INS-05-109
Maine Employers' Mutual Insurance Co. Perry Transport, Inc. v. Maine Employers' Mutual Insurance Company INS-05-106
Maine Employers' Mutual Insurance Co. Dyer Straights Transportation, Inc. v. Maine Employers' Mutual Insurance Company INS-05-104
Maine Employers' Mutual Insurance Co. Lincoln Paper & Tissue, LLC v. Maine Employers' Mutual Insurance Company INS-05-103
Maine Employers' Mutual Insurance Co. Project Staffing, Inc., One Source Preferred, Inc., and Special Teams, Inc. v. Maine Employers' Mutual Insurance Company and National Council on Compensation Insurance INS-05-101
Maine Employers' Mutual Insurance Co. Portland Airport Limousine Co., Inc. dba PALCO Air Cargo v. Maine Employers' Mutual Insurance Company INS-04-109
Maine Employers' Mutual Insurance Co. Mega Industries, LLC v. Maine Employers' Mutual Insurance Company and National Council on Compensation Insurance, Inc. INS-04-107
Maine Employers' Mutual Insurance Co. Penquis C.A.P., Inc. v. Maine Employers' Mutual Insurance Company and National Council on Compensation Insurance, Inc. INS-04-105
Maine Employers' Mutual Insurance Co. Support Solutions, Inc. v. Maine Employers' Mutual Insurance Company and Liberty Mutual Insurance Company INS-04-104
Maine Employers' Mutual Insurance Co. Terravecchia Building and Restoration, Inc. v. Maine Employers' Mutual Insurance Company and Ford Insurance Agency, Inc. INS-04-103
Maine Employers' Mutual Insurance Co. Sharkey Builders, Inc. v. Maine Employers' Mutual Insurance Company INS-04-100
Maine Employers' Mutual Insurance Co. Northland Roofing, Inc. v. Maine Employers' Mutual Insurance Company INS-03-450
Maine Employers' Mutual Insurance Co. North American Whitewater Expeditions, Inc. v. Maine Employers' Mutual Insurance Company INS-03-449
Maine Employers' Mutual Insurance Co. Reconsideration - Perry Transport, Inc. v. Maine Employers' Mutual Insurance Company INS-03-412 (Reconsideration)
Maine Employers' Mutual Insurance Co. Perry Transport, Inc. v. Maine Employers' Mutual Insurance Company INS-03-412
Maine Employers' Mutual Insurance Co. (Final) Combined Management, Inc. vs. Maine Employers' Mutual Insurance Company INS-02-789 (Final)
Maine Employers' Mutual Insurance Co. Combined Management, Inc. vs. Maine Employers' Mutual Insurance Company INS-02-789
Maine Employers' Mutual Insurance Co. Geary Bonville dba NCT, et al. v. Maine Employers' Mutual Insurance Company INS-00-14
Maine Employers' Mutual Insurance Co. New Meadows Abatement v. Maine Employers' Mutual Insurance Company INS-99-16
Maine Employers' Mutual Insurance Co. Clyde Webb v. Maine Employers' Mutual Insurance Company INS-99-15 (Reconsideration)
Maine Employers' Mutual Insurance Co. Clyde Webb v. Maine Employers' Mutual Insurance Company INS-99-15
Maine Employers' Mutual Insurance Co. Charles Bugbee, d/b/a Independent Transport v. Maine Employers' Mutual Insurance Company INS-98-8
Maine Employers' Mutual Insurance Co. Colonial Plastering v. Maine Employers' Mutual Insurance Company, et al. INS-97-23
Maine Employers' Mutual Insurance Co. SDF Management, Inc. v. Maine Employers' Mutual Insurance Company, et al. INS-95-34
Maine Health Care Assoc. Maine Health Care Association Workers' Compensation Fund INS-05-600
National Council on Compensation Insurance Project Staffing, Inc., One Source Preferred, Inc., and Special Teams, Inc. v. Maine Employers' Mutual Insurance Company and National Council on Compensation Insurance INS-05-101
National Council on Compensation Insurance Mega Industries, LLC v. Maine Employers' Mutual Insurance Company and National Council on Compensation Insurance, Inc. INS-04-107
National Council on Compensation Insurance Penquis C.A.P., Inc. v. Maine Employers' Mutual Insurance Company and National Council on Compensation Insurance, Inc. INS-04-105
National Council on Compensation Insurance Portland Airport Limousine Co., Inc., dba Palco Air Cargo v. American Interstate Insurance Company and National Council on Compensation Insurance, Inc. INS-04-102
National Council on Compensation Insurance Robert Crawford dba Colonial Plastering v. National Council on Compensation Insurance, Inc. INS-03-434
National Council on Compensation Insurance Roland and Janice Husset dba Hussey's Paint and Decorating v. Hanover Insurance Company and National Council on Compensation Insurance INS-02-504
National Council on Compensation Insurance Gilbert Law Offices, P.A. v. National Council on Compensation Insurance, et al. INS-99-2 (Final)
National Council on Compensation Insurance Gilbert Law Offices, P.A. v. National Council on Compensation Insurance, et al. INS-99-2
Norguard Insurance Co. Workout Fitness Store v. Norguard Insurance Company INS-01-2520
Star Insurance Co. Portland Airport Limousine Co., Inc., dba Palco Air Cargo v. Star Insurance Company INS-03-415
Wausau Underwriters Insurance Co. Crowe Rope Industries, LLC v. Wausau Underwriters Insurance Company INS-00-11

Other

   
Mark A. Perry   INS 08-800
Bankers Life and Casualty Co. Bankers Life and Casualty Company and Mary E. Matarazzo INS-04-229

 

Last Updated: January 2, 2009